The Microsoft Surface Pro 4 Review: Raising The Barby Brett Howse on October 21, 2015 9:00 AM EST
It is almost hard to believe that only a few short years ago, Microsoft had no hand in the PC systems or tablet markets. Though the company has been into hardware for some time, producing peripherals since the earliest days and gaming consoles since the turn of the millennium, the company has otherwise avoided competing with its OEM customers by producing complete systems. Then came the Microsoft Surface line. The very first Surface was 2012's ill-fated Surface RT, but a few months later in 2013, Microsoft released their first take on an x86 Surface convertible tablet. The first Surface Pro was a sizable 2.0 lb monster tablet which packed Ultrabook class components into a chassis that was over 0.5-inches thick. It was powerful, but heavy and the 16:9 form factor was not ideal for a tablet.
More recently, in 2014 Microsoft launched the Surface Pro 3. Microsoft’s third generation tablet fixed almost all of the issues with the original two versions. They moved to a 3:2 display and up in size to a 12-inch panel. Amazingly the Surface Pro 3 came just sixteen months after the original Surface Pro, and in between there was also a Surface Pro 2. Microsoft was keen to iterate their design and with the Surface Pro 3, they had a real winning combination. The chassis slimmed down to just 0.36-inches, and the weight dropped to 1.76 lbs. Larger, yet thinner and lighter, the Surface Pro 3 felt much more like a tablet than the previous generations. Surface Pro 3 was the success that the Redmond company was hoping for with the original design, and for the first time in their short history of building PC hardware, Microsoft was now the one being followed.
Surface 3 (left) Surface Pro 4 (center) Surface Pro 3 (right)
Part of that success was not just the tablet, but also the accessories. Microsoft’s Type Cover was a way to easily transform the tablet into a notebook, and the pen has always been a feature of the Surface Pro line. To try and gain success in the enterprise, Microsoft also created a Surface Dock which could be used to quickly transform the tablet into a desktop PC. The dock was an interesting thing, because Microsoft sort of painted themselves in a corner with it, promising buyers that the dock would work with the next generation Surface as well. Luckily it was a good corner to be in. The Surface Pro 3’s form factor was one of its strongest points.
I bring up this history because the Surface lineup feels like it has been around for a long time, when in fact the Pro lineup is only about two and a half years old. In that short time, Microsoft has gone from having no place in the PC hardware market to iterating their design four times and having a strong brand. There were some low points, but Surface has clawed its way back and we now have the fourth generation Surface Pro to take a look at.
Surface Pro 4 (left) Surface Pro 3 (right)
Sizing Up Surface Pro 4
Microsoft has said that there are over 500 new parts in the Surface Pro 4. One of the most obvious is the new, larger display. The display has been stretched out from 12-inches to 12.3-inches, with Microsoft retaining the same device footprint by reducing the thickness of the bezel to accomodate. Microsoft has also increased the resolution of the display from 2160x1440 to 2736x1824, going well beyond the modest increase in resolution required to retain Surface Pro 3's 216 PPI pixel density. The end result is a pixel density of 267 PPI, which just edges out a number of large form factor tablets, including the yet-to-launch iPad Pro.
Many of the other changes are under the virtual hood. After launching Surface Pro 3 with Haswell in 2014, Microsoft - like so many manufacturers - opted to skip the short-lived Broadwell generation of Intel CPUs in favor of making the larger jump to Skylake. Skylake brings with it notable increases in both CPU and GPU performance, particularly in the mobile space thanks to a series of optimizations and the use of Intel's leading 14nm manufacturing node.
Meanwhile much like the Surface Pro 3, the Surface Pro 4 will be offered with three processor choices. For Surface Pro 4 this is a Core m3-6Y30, a Core i5-6300U, and a Core i7-6650U. Yes, Surface Pro 4 is now offered in a fanless model. The move to Core m3 may surprise some, but don’t forget that the Core i3 version of the Surface Pro 3 used the Core i3-4020Y. The “Y” series from Intel is the ultra-low power Core lineup that was rebranded as Core M with Broadwell. Having a “Y” CPU in a Surface Pro is not new, but the latest and greatest Core m3 model has a TDP of just 4.5 Watts - down from 11.5W on the Core i3 Surface Pro 3 - which allows it to be completely fanless.
Those that noticed the processor numbers may have noticed the “50” on the end of the i7 version. This designates that the i7 model comes with Intel’s Iris Graphics 540. This is a GT3e GPU, which offers substaintially better GPU performance thanks to a much larger GPU paired with 64MB of eDRAM.
On the memory side of matters, the Surface Pro 4 offers between 4GB and 16 GB of RAM depending on the specific SKU, retaining the same 4GB minimum as the Surface Pro 3 while marking the first time a 16GB SKU has been offered in the Surface Pro family. Meanwhile for storage, the SSD situation has been dramatically improved with PCIe 3.0 NVMe drives. The 64 GB model is no more, with the base Surface Pro 4 now coming with 128 GB, and a 1 TB model will be available soon as well.
|Microsoft Surface Pro 4|
|As Tested, Core i5-6300U, 8 GB RAM, 256 GB SSD|
|Processor||Intel Core m3-6Y30 (2C/4T, 0.9-2.2GHz, 4MB L3, 14nm, 4.5w)
Intel Core i5-6300U (2C/4T, 2.4-3.0GHz, 3MB L3, 14nm, 15w)
Intel Core i7-6650U (2C/4T, 2.2-3.4GHz, 4MB L3, 14nm, 15w)
|Memory||4 GB, 8 GB, 16 GB Dual-Channel DDR3L-1600|
|Graphics||Intel Core m3-6Y30
Intel HD 515 (24 EUs, 300-850 MHz)
Intel Core i5-6300U
Intel HD Graphics 520 (24 EUs, 300-1000 MHz)
Intel Core i7-6650U
Intel Iris Graphics 540 (48 EUs, 64 MB eDRAM, 300-1050 MHz)
|Display||12.3" 2736x1824 3:2 PixelSense
Samsung IGZO Display, Touch and Pen support
100% sRGB color, individually calibrated panels
|Storage||128 GB, 256 GB, 512 GB, 1 TB PCIe NVMe (review model Toshiba XG3)|
|Networking||Marvell AVASTAR Wireless-AC (802.11ac, 2x2:2, 866Mpbs Max, 2.4 and 5GHz)
|Audio||Stereo Speakers (front facing)
|Battery||39 Wh Battery
24 Watt(Core m3) or 36 Watt (Core i5/i7) A/C Adapter with 5 Watt USB port
|Right Side||USB 3.0
Surface Connect Port (charging and docking)
|Left Side||Headset Jack|
|Dimensions||292 x 201 x 8.4 mm (11.5 x 7.9 x 0.33 inches)|
|Weight||Core m3: 766 grams (1.69 lbs)
Core i5/i7: 786 grams (1.73 lbs)
|Cameras||Rear: 8.0 MP auto-focus
Front: 5.0 MP auto-focus and Windows Hello support
|Extras||Surface Pen (included)
micro SD card slot
|Pricing||128 GB Intel Core m3 with 4GB of RAM: $899
128 GB Intel Core i5 with 4GB of RAM: $999
256 GB Intel Core i5 with 8GB of RAM: $1299
256 GB Intel Core i7 with 8GB of RAM: $1599
256 GB Intel Core i7 with 16GB of RAM: $1799
512 GB Intel Core i7 with 16GB of RAM: $2199
1 TB Intel Core i7 with 16GB of RAM: $2699
Build to order available for further customization of configurations
Other new features include a custom display chipset which Microsoft is branding the G5. The use of G5 allowed Microsoft to integrate touch and pen support, with Microsoft utilizing a custom solution to help drive down both the pen and touch input latency. They are also leveraging the GPU to accelerate touch and pen input to further drive down latency. Speaking of the pen, the latest model now offers 1024 levels of pressure, up from 256 in the Surface Pro 3. Microsoft purchased the N-Trig technology and are using it on all of their Surface lineup now. The new pen also offers interchangeable pen tips to give you a different size and feel as appropriate.
The chassis is also revised, and is now slightly thinner and lighter than the outgoing model. The display size was increased, but the dimensions of the tablet were not. Microsoft cut into some of the surrounding bezel to achieve this. They likely could have gone for even less bezel, but it would make it difficult to use as a tablet if they went much further. Subtly, the Windows key is no longer on the right side. It is no longer needed with Windows 10 because the Start Button is always on the screen, and removing it removes one common complaint with the Surface Pro 3, which was inadvertently pressing the button on the bezel either with your palm while using the pen, or even when just handing the tablet. I for one am glad to see it gone.
The Surface Pro 4 is, at first glance, an evolutionary update over the Surface Pro 3. That is not necessarily a bad thing. The move to Skylake as well as some of the many changes under the covers should be a big improvement over the outgoing model though. Let’s dive in.
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
MattL - Wednesday, October 28, 2015 - linkWould love it if you guys could get your hands on a SP4 m3 model and see if it has any better battery life in your standardized tests.
yvizel - Wednesday, October 28, 2015 - linkI second that.
Any chance you will have a follow up?
gcoupe - Thursday, October 29, 2015 - linkComprehensive and thorough review. I missed a mention of one thing though - the fact that the rear camera of the SP4 is now auto-focus, unlike the ludicrous fixed-focus version in the SP3.
It is at last possible to take clear photos of documents with a Surface Pro device.
jsntech - Thursday, October 29, 2015 - linkBrett,
Thanks for the review. Did you notice any of these issues being pretty widely reported?
I was really looking forward to ordering one until I saw all this hell breaking loose. Gives me bad flashbacks of the SP1 I had to send back due to bug overload. Hope 3 versions later it would be better, but maybe not...
Brett Howse - Thursday, November 5, 2015 - linkSP4 was pretty good. I didn't have any real issues with it. There was one issue with the pre-production units which was fixed for release, and the release one has not exhibited that issue.
CallsignVega - Sunday, November 1, 2015 - linkHow in the world do people do detailed tests like this and not take the ten seconds to test for PWM dimming in the display?
philipm785 - Tuesday, November 3, 2015 - linkGreat review. As usual, you guys delve deeper than the competition. One question: did you have any success connecting the SP4 to external high resolution (ie > 1920 x 1080) displays? I just picked one up and for the life of me can't get it to drive my display higher than 1920x1080 even though my SP3 drives it at 2560x1080.
Brett Howse - Thursday, November 5, 2015 - linkI recently got the dock to test out so I'll give it a try.
Telex - Friday, November 6, 2015 - linkAs of 11/6/2016 with newest insider Windows 10 and appropriate drivers, this product does NOT deliver. Not only does the USB controller not function correctly, it does not support dual 4k monitors as advertised. I have spent hours and hours with Microsoft technical support and they are unable to help me. I just called one last time, and they said there isn't even an ETA on it being fixed. I will change my review if their engineers can ever get the product's issues resolved. Until then, I would stay FAR away from this device. If I could give "0" stars, I would have done so.
Telex - Friday, November 6, 2015 - linkSorry, I am referring to the new Surface Dock with the Surface Book.